Nutmeg FC

Nutmeg FC

Hearts Are Bossing The League With A 4-4-2. And It Isn't 2006

Derek McInnes (usually) rolls out a simple old-school formation, executed to perfection and with devastating scoring results, to the chagrin of data crunching nerds everywhere

Adam Clery's avatar
Adam Clery
Oct 07, 2025
∙ Paid
1
Share

This post is for paid subscribers. To unlock everything on Nutmeg FC AND receive every issue of our 200-page quarterly magazine straight to your door FOR A YEAR, sign up for the Nutmeg Season Ticket today. Subscribe below.

Select ‘Annual’ to buy your Season Ticket – and we’ll be in touch directly for your postal address


Here’s a sentence for you. Seven games into the season (which feels just about on the cusp of when you’re actually allowed to seriously look at the table), Heart of Midlothian not only sit top, but have scored more goals than both Celtic and Rangers.

Slight caveat: I write this in the aftermath of an Edinburgh derby that felt more like watching two rival school classes boot shite out of each other on a blustery lunchtime than, say, a professional game of association football. Anyway, while Celtic netted three times in their narrow Sunday victory over Motherwell before we Completed The Round™, Hearts have still outscored them by five goals.

Derek McInnes has, across this admittedly small sample size, made Hearts the best team in Scotland. That is one fact. More interestingly though, for both me and anyone who’d open an article with my name on it, he’s done it — usually — with a proper 4-4-2. Which is a more interesting fact because it’s not how football is supposed to work anymore.

Keep reading with a 7-day free trial

Subscribe to Nutmeg FC to keep reading this post and get 7 days of free access to the full post archives.

Already a paid subscriber? Sign in
Adam Clery's avatar
A guest post by
Adam Clery
Never-that-serious analysis and insight from Football Tactics "Expert", face of FourFourTwo video, and 0x award-winning presenter Adam Clery.
Subscribe to Adam
© 2025 Nutmeg Magazine
Privacy ∙ Terms ∙ Collection notice
Start writingGet the app
Substack is the home for great culture